Summary
- A cookie banner only helps if it actually controls what loads. In our pilot scan, 12 of the 19 clinic sites with a banner still fired advertising tags before the visitor chose anything.
- The OAIC has said a banner or pop-up at the first visit can be part of the reasonable steps to notify people, but consent for health information must be specific. A generic “we use cookies” pop-up was found insufficient in the Medmate decision.
- Google Consent Mode adjusts Google’s own tags. Its “advanced” setup still sends some data before consent. Other platforms’ tags need to be blocked separately.
- For the most sensitive pages, the simplest fix is often not to load advertising tags there at all.
When clinics learn about the OAIC’s tracking pixel decisions, the first instinct is often to add a cookie banner. A banner can be part of the answer. On its own, it often changes very little. This guide explains what banners do, what they don’t, and how to tell whether yours is doing its job.
Where Australian law comes in
For clinics, the obligations that matter come from the Privacy Act and the Australian Privacy Principles (APPs). The OAIC’s guidance on tracking pixels does not ban them. It says organisations must notify people clearly about what is collected, and must obtain consent before collecting sensitive information such as health information. It also says express opt-in consent should generally be sought1.
In the June 2026 determinations, the Commissioner said consent must be informed, voluntary, current and specific, and that for sensitive information the level of specificity required is higher2. Medmate had introduced a cookie pop-up shortly before the investigation began. It did not mention pixels, Meta or TikTok, and was found insufficient23. The Commissioner also found that a privacy policy alone does not meet the duty to notify people at or before collection2.
The OAIC’s report on its health website inspection suggests that reasonable steps could include a banner or pop-up at the first visit, with a way to opt out4. So a banner is relevant. The question is what it does.
Three kinds of banner
1. Notice-only banners
These display a message such as “This site uses cookies” with an OK button. Nothing on the page waits for the click. Every tag loads as normal. A banner like this informs, at best. It does not change what the platforms receive.
2. Consent tools that don’t block
Many sites install a proper consent management platform (CMP), such as Cookiebot, OneTrust, Usercentrics or CookieYes, but the tags are never connected to it. The banner records choices, while Google Tag Manager or hard-coded scripts load advertising tags anyway. In our pilot Clinic Pixel Index, 19 of 94 sites showed a banner or consent tool, and on 12 of them advertising tags fired before the visitor clicked anything5.
3. Banners with prior blocking
Here, advertising and analytics tags wait until the visitor agrees. If they decline or ignore the banner, the tags never load. This is the only kind of banner that changes what an ad platform receives. Combined with clear wording that names the platforms involved, it comes closest to the specific consent the Commissioner described.
What Google Consent Mode does and doesn’t do
Google Consent Mode lets a website tell Google’s tags what the visitor chose. Its consent types include ad_storage, ad_user_data, ad_personalization and analytics_storage6. Google is explicit that the site owner is responsible for obtaining consent, and for making sure both Google and third-party tags behave according to the visitor’s choice6.
There are two ways to run it:
- Basic consent mode blocks Google tags from loading until the visitor interacts with the banner. No data is sent to Google before that interaction6.
- Advanced consent mode loads Google tags straight away with consent denied by default. Until consent is granted, the tags send cookieless pings that Google uses for modelling. According to Google’s documentation, page addresses can still be included in those pings6.
For a clinic, that difference matters. If your condition and treatment page addresses describe health needs, advanced mode can still send those addresses to Google before anyone has agreed. Mallesons noted that both providers in the OAIC decisions had the means to use notification tools, including the consent mode functionality offered by pixel providers3. Consent Mode is a tool, not a finish line.
Remember the other platforms. Consent Mode changes the behaviour of Google tags. Meta, Microsoft, Pinterest, LinkedIn, TikTok, Snap and Reddit tags need to be held back by your consent tool or by Tag Manager triggers. In our pilot, those platforms received many of the sensitive page addresses we observed5.
Test your banner in five minutes
- Open a private or incognito window and your browser’s developer tools (F12), then select the Network tab.
- Load your homepage. Do not touch the banner.
- Filter the network list for
facebook.com/tr,googleadservices,doubleclick,bat.bing,analytics.tiktokandct.pinterest. Anything that appears fired before consent. - Now click Reject or Decline, then visit a service page. Check the same filters. Anything that appears fired despite a refusal.
- Finally, accept and confirm the tags load. If they don’t, your measurement is broken, which is a separate problem worth fixing.
If you use Google Consent Mode, you can also look for gcs or gcd parameters in Google requests. They carry the consent state Google’s tags have received6.
Wording that is specific enough
We can’t give legal advice, but the decisions point to some practical principles. Specific means the banner should say which kinds of tools you use (for example advertising and analytics), name the main platforms, and explain in a sentence what they are used for. It should make declining as easy as accepting. It should not imply that the site won’t work without advertising cookies. And it should link to a privacy policy that matches what the banner says. Our privacy policy guide covers that side.
When a banner isn’t the right fix
The OAIC suggests considering whether pixels are needed on particular pages at all, and notes that where simply visiting a site reveals sensitive information, it may be preferable to avoid pixels1. A banner asks every visitor to make a decision. Removing advertising tags from condition, treatment and booking pages takes the decision away from the patient entirely, and is often simpler to maintain. Campaign measurement can often rely on a small number of generic, consent-gated events instead. See our privacy-safe dataLayer guide.
Checklist
- Confirm that no advertising tag fires before the visitor makes a choice.
- Confirm that no advertising tag fires after the visitor declines.
- Make sure the banner names the kinds of tools and main platforms, and that declining is as easy as accepting.
- If you use Google Consent Mode, decide deliberately between basic and advanced, knowing that advanced still sends pings before consent.
- Hold back non-Google tags through your consent tool or Tag Manager triggers.
- Consider removing advertising tags from condition, treatment and booking pages altogether.
- Keep your banner wording, your privacy policy and your actual tags in step, and re-test after every change.
See what your own website shares
The free Akesis scan checks your homepage for advertising and analytics tags, whether they fire before consent, and what they receive. It takes about a minute and needs no install.
Run a free scanSources
- OAIC, Tracking pixels and privacy obligations, 4 November 2024. www.oaic.gov.au/privacy/privacy-guidance-for-organisations-and-government-agencies/organisations/tracking-pixels-and-privacy-obligations
- Clayton Utz, OAIC determines the use of tracking pixels “did not track”, 8 July 2026. www.claytonutz.com/insights/2026/july/oaic-determines-the-use-of-tracking-pixels-did-not-track
- Mallesons, Privacy Commissioner zooms in on tracking pixels, 3 July 2026. www.mallesons.com/au/en/insights/latest-thinking/privacy-commissioner-zooms-in-on-tracking-pixels.html
- OAIC, Your life, pixelated: how tracking pixels watch your every click, 24 June 2026. www.oaic.gov.au/news/blog/your-life,-pixelated-how-tracking-pixels-watch-your-every-click
- Akesis, The Australian Clinic Pixel Index 2026 (pilot, n=94), 27 October 2026.
- Google for Developers, Consent mode overview. developers.google.com/tag-platform/security/concepts/consent-mode
Sources were checked on 27 October 2026. Links to third-party sites are provided for reference; Akesis is not affiliated with the organisations listed.